Critique Paper Rubric

3421
CriteriaExcellent
4
Good
3
Fair
2
NI
1
IntroductionIntroduction made use of a creative strategy to produce a strong desire on the reader to read further.Introduction’s strategy produced some desire on the reader to read further.The introduction’s strategy made the reader indifferent to the text.The introduction’s strategy actually made the reader stop reading the text.
Focus and CoherenceAll the details connect well to the topic and to each other.All details connected well to the topic, but some are not well-connected to each other.Some details are not connected well to the topic or to each other.Most details are not well-connected to the topic or to each other.
ElaborationDetails were more than enough to elaborate the main idea.Details were enough to elaborate the main idea.Details were barely enough to elaborate the main idea.Details were clearly lacking.
ConclusionThe conclusion provided a good dosing that made the text notable.The conclusion was adequate to dose the text but not make it notable.The conclusion left the text somewhat hanging.The conclusion was actually Inappropriate to the ending of the text.
ConventionSpelling, grammar, and punctuations are all excellent.Spelling, grammar, and punctuations are all good.One element of convention is not done well.Two or more elements of conventions are not done well.